Rotary Meeting of May 24, 2017

Jeff True of the Ithaca Rotary Club gave an interesting and informative talk on the New York State Constitution entitled “Shall there be a convention to amend the Constitution and revise the same?” Highlights included:

Voters are asked every twenty years whether or not to call a Constitutional Convention .
Our current constitution was adopted as a single package in 1894.
Calls for a convention were rejected in 1977 and 1997; the next referendum will be in the fall of 2017.

Potential Issues:

    • Legislature (terms of members)
    • Bill of Rights
    • Suffrage
    • Executive Branch (Governor’s Power to Reorganize)
    • Public Officials
    • Judiciary – Structure of the Courts; Selection of Judges

Reasons for Optimism:

    • Nothing in the State Constitution can diminish rights guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.
    • Only a Constitutional Convention can deal with the fundamental structure and powers of the legislature.

Preparing for a Convention – 2017:

  • Efforts to generate public discussion and awareness
  • The most important words in the New York State Constitution: “We the People…Do Establish this Constitution.”
  • The Constitution affirms that its source is not the legislature, not the governor, nor the judges, but the people themselves.
  • Nothing can be inserted in the Constitution without the approval of the voters.